
Public service reform should begin with purpose, not with a choice between public and private ownership.
Mutuo has published a new report, The case for mutuals in public services: Purpose, ownership and accountability in the public interest, written by Peter Hunt.
For too long, debates about public service reform have focused on who should deliver services: government, private businesses or other providers. But there is a more fundamental question: how can institutions be designed to remain committed to the public interest over time?
Public ownership alone does not guarantee responsiveness to the people who use services. Equally, private ownership can create tensions between the interests of shareholders and the wider public.
Mutuals offer a different approach.
By embedding public purpose in their constitutions, protecting assets for long-term benefit and giving employees, service users and communities a meaningful role in governance, mutuals can bring ownership, accountability and service delivery into closer alignment.
The report draws on examples including NHS foundation trusts, Greenwich Leisure, Glas Cymru and co-operative schools to demonstrate how different mutual models can support public service delivery.
It also recognises that mutuality is not a universal solution. Good governance, professional management, financial resilience and effective public scrutiny remain essential.
The report argues that mutuals should become a mainstream option whenever public services are established, reorganised or reformed.
Rather than treating mutuality as an exception, policymakers should consider how collective stewardship and meaningful participation can help create institutions that serve the public interest across generations.
As the report concludes:
“Public purpose should be more than an obligation imposed upon an institution. It should be the reason that institution exists, the principle around which it is owned and governed, and the standard by which its success is judged.”
Mutuo believes that public service reform should be about more than choosing between different providers. It should be about building institutions whose ownership, governance and accountability arrangements protect the interests of the people and communities they exist to serve.
Read the full report: Public Service Mutuals 2026